Thursday, March 20, 2008

Balancing Acts

Book #24: The 9/11 Report: A Graphic Adaptation by Sid Jacobson and Ernie Colon.

I got this book at NCTE, too. I've put off reading it, but it was gripping - especially at the beginning when they were talking about that day. They really did an amazing job of it and used the graphic novel form to their advantage: the four planes are shown as parallel timelines, so you can compare what happened when (and who knew what when) or follow one flight all the way through and then read the next.
That's my analytic response. My emotional response is that I was crying as I read it. I didn't think I would, but it was almost a flashback experience.
The authors have a statement on Amazon about why they chose to write this version in the form of a graphic novel. It's great - it compares comics to the cave paintings at Altamira. Nice.

From the last paragraph of the forward, written by the chair and vice chair of the 9/11 Commission: "The safety and security of our country require a well-informed public to hold its elected leaders to account. Have our leaders done all that they can and should to protect the American people? It is up to each of us to insist that they do. As we stated in our original preface to the commission report, we hope that this graphic version will encourage our fellow citizens to study, reflect--and act."

Yes. Absolutely. On all counts: that we need a "well-informed public" and that we should "hold [our] leaders to account" and that we should work to protect ourselves from terrorist attacks. Yes. And, that is not enough. It is a delicate and difficult balancing act: to protect us from terrorist attacks... and from attacks on our civil rights.


Book #25: Judith Viorst's Alexander and the Wonderful, Marvelous, Excellent, Terrific Ninety Days.

I needed something silly, family-oriented, stable, real, and non-terrifying to balance out the 9/11 Report. This was it.

The funny thing is that when I ordered it online from the library, I was mad at her for her title. I was a little appalled that she'd so clearly plagiarized from one of my favorite books from when I was little: Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day.
I guess that's what happens when you pick a book without looking at the cover! I was embarrassed and relieved when I read on the front cover that SHE wrote that amazing children's book. And then I read the inside front cover, and it asked: "Whatever became of Alexander after that famously bad day? And did you know that Judith Viorst is his mother?"

The subtitle of this book says it all: An Almost Completely Honest Account of What Happened to Our Family When Our Youngest Son, His Wife, Their Baby, Their Toddler, and Their Five-Year-Old Came to Live with Us for Three Months.

I loved her tone: honest, funny, admitting that she was perhaps a little bit obsessed with the cleanliness of her many velvet-covered chairs. I liked it best when she talked about her own family. She added a bunch of anecdotes at the end of the book about other people's experiences with living in a three-generation homes, and I didn't enjoy them quite as much (although some of them were quite funny).

I also loved the quote on the page before the first chapter, attributed to Sayings of the Jewish Buddhist: "Be here now. Be someplace else later. Is that so complicated?"

Well, yes. It is complicated for me... but I'm working on it! It's also complicated for our government... and we all need to work on that.

Wednesday, March 19, 2008

Scott Westerfield's Uglies Series

Books 20, 21, 22, and 23: Scott Westerfield's Uglies, Pretties, Specials, and Extras.

I love science fiction. I fell in love with it when I read Margaret L'Engle's A Wrinkle in Time in elementary school. And I love series books (they take more than one day to read - it extends the experience).

So it's weird that when one of my students told me that I must read this series two years ago I didn't jump on it. I just got these books a few weeks ago, and I've run through them in no time at all.

I love how science fiction poses a "what if" question and answers it. What if pretty were the only important thing? What if we could re-wire our brains? What if other people could re-wire our brains? What great questions.

Sometimes, I'll admit, sci fi can be deliberately confusing at the beginning of the book. But these books are written with teens as their main audience - so while there is a lot of techy language and futuristic slang, it's accessible. And, it's accessible without going to the opposite edge and being too obvious.








Wednesday, March 5, 2008

Looking For Alaska


Book #19: Looking for Alaska by John Green


I woke up this morning to a phone call from school saying it's a SNOW DAY! I'm delighted - but I am going to have to shorten up the requirements for the multigenre research paper, or we'll never finish it by the end of the marking period. Yikes. I wish I could just give an extension - but it messes up my students' grades to have a big project cross over into the next marking period. I've tried that before, and my students told me NEVER to do that again. So I won't.

Over breakfast this morning, I finished Looking for Alaska. Maybe finished is the wrong word - I think I'm going to have it in my head a long time. Errand #1 for today: go buy everything else John Green has ever written. I loved this book. I've been meaning to read it since last year when a friend recommended it to me, and then I was curious because when I checked out his blog John said his book was being challenged at a high school in New York.

When I was reading the first half of his book, I saw why. There is, as John says, some "edgy" material, and I wasn't sure what I thought yet.

Then I finished the book. And I get it. I get why those two teachers want to teach this book in their 11th grade (English?) class. I get why my students will love this book.

The first paragraph: "one hundred thirty-six days before / The week before I left my family and Florida and the rest of my minor life to go to boarding school in Alabama, my mother insisted on throwing me a going-away party. To say that I had low expectations would be to underestimate the matter dramatically. Although I was more or less forced to invite all my 'school friends,' i.e., the ragtag bunch of drama people and English geeks I sat with by social necessity in the cavernous cafeteria of my public school, I knew they wouldn't come. Still, my mother persevered, awash in the delusion that I had kept my popularity secret from her all these years. She cooked a small mountain of artichoke dip. She festooned our living room in green and yellow streamers, the colors of my new school. She bought two dozen champagne poppers and placed them around the edge of our coffee table."

There's a bunch of "bonus material" at the end of the book, which includes an interview with John. I couldn't put the book down at the last page, so I read it all before I admitted that I was actually done. Here's a quote from the last answer: "...I believe in hope, in what is sometimes called 'radical hope.' I believe that there is hope for us all, even amid the suffering - and maybe even inside the suffering. And that's why I write fiction, probably. It's my attempt to keep that fragile strand of radical hope, to build a fire in the darkness."

Yes.

Tuesday, March 4, 2008

Ethan, Suspended



Book #18: Ethan, Suspended by Pamela Ehrenberg is one of the many books I got at NCTE in New York last fall. This one's special because the author signed it for my students. Too cool. I have to admit I might not have gotten this book without that added incentive of an author's signing - and if I had left it on the shelf I would really have missed out. I really liked this book - it surprised me, because it had pigeon-holed it as a "boy book." Big mistake - and, it turns out, that's among the themes of the book (both the big mistakes and the pigeon-holing, that is).


Ethan does something that is so horrible that not only is he suspended, but his mom sends him to live with his grandparents. I can't tell you what he does - because him figuring out how to deal with it himself and then tell people what he did is a big part of the book. Ehrenberg also brings in ideas about teens dealing with their parents' divorce, finding new friends, figuring out how to recover from big mistakes, civil rights, and the Washington riots of 1968. It's a lot - but it flows and I needed to know what happened next.

The other nice thing Ehrenberg does is offer resources at the end of the book about civil rights and the riots. We're writing multigenre research papers in my English 9 class right now, so it's possible I'm a little focused - but even if my students didn't look stuff up, they'll know that the author did. Which is nice.

The first two paragraphs: "It feels like I'm running, faster than I've ever run before. Past the library and the Whole Foods, past Josh and Caleb and Tyler, who are running too, past everything in Maple Heights. I feel like I'm crossing Meadowfalls Road, coming up on I-76, almost out of sight. / But I'm not running. I'm standing still. My feet feel like they're glued to the sidewalk by giant wads of bubble gum."

This book, especially, makes me think I need another blog - a public one that I invite my students to read (and maybe to write for) that focuses just on young adult books/books for my students. Just what I need: another project! :)

Monday, March 3, 2008

Quilting





Book #17: I got Art Quilt Workbook by Jane Davila & Elin Waterston from the library.



BIG mistake. I'm going to have to go buy it, because it's due today and I want to try ALL of their ideas! Normally I post the first paragraph, but with this kind of book that doesn't really capture the tone. So - from the section on "The Creative Process" on p. 11: "Try something relatively mindless but still within your medium (a simple pieced baby quilt or placemats, for example), or try something completely different, yet still creative. Sign up for a ceramics class, a photography class, or even a tap dancing class! Learning a new skill can reawaken creativity in all areas."


The book has a great balance of information about design, the creative process, making art quilts a business, and it has SO many great samples - by the authors and by their students. I also loved that they structured it like a class - there are specific assignments at the end of each chapter to get you started on trying the new techniques. They also have great quotes about making art - I'm going to have to make some of them into little posters for my classroom. For example, they quote Salvador Dali: "Have no fear of perfection; you'll never reach it." OK, maybe that one is more for me than for my students!


I was so inspired to make my own series of art quilts while reading this book - the art quilts are going to have to wait - I'm in middle of a queen-sized quilt for my husband. It has 190 blocks with 8 pieces in each block. It's going to be amazing - when I finish. I have 24 blocks done. Do NOT ask me when I started. OH - here's an image of the book I'm working from - I'm making the quilt on the cover. Yes, I'm nutty - but my husband picked the pattern. It's actually quite sweet - I've been focused on making quilts for my neices and nephews, and he interrupted one day to announce that it was HIS TURN and they were just going to have to wait. :D

It's interesting how differently I read this kind of book than I would read a novel. First I read it front to back. Then I re-read the sections with the most interesting techniques. Then I just looked at the art quilts. Then I re-read the whole book - from back to front. I've read it over and over again, and I notice something new each time. I'll have to talk with my students about this - I'm not sure they see non-fiction as being that different from a novel. We'll have to talk - and I'll have to get them to make connections to what they read (online, automotive instructions, etc.).